September 4, 2003
Purdue food scientists improve testing of health supplements
WEST LAFAYETTE, Ind. Purdue University researchers have discovered a faster, less expensive method to test the quality and purity of dietary supplement oils, such as flax seed, borage seed and grape seed oil, often touted as cures for many human maladies.
The research results are published in the September issue of the Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry and on the journal's Web site.
"This study brings analytical chemistry, food science, nutritional sciences and consumer interest together," said Lisa Mauer, assistant professor of food science. "Consumers want the salad dressing brand they buy to taste the same every time. The same is true for special types of oils, which are more expensive than a general cooking oil. You expect what you buy to be high quality and contain what is on the label."
Consumers are concerned about purity because of taste, safety, health benefits and cost, she said. While oils that are less pure may be less expensive, they may lose the flavor or health benefits, and some can even be detrimental to health. In addition, consumer demand for food and food additives is increasingly for organic or 100 percent natural products.
Manufacturers of health supplements and drugs are concerned with purity because of quality control issues that impact safety of the substances and company economics.
To address these concerns, scientists search for fast, effective, inexpensive ways of differentiating between different ingredients in this case dietary supplement oils.
Purdue researchers used infrared spectroscopy and statistical analysis to classify samples of 14 dietary supplement oils and five common food oils. The scientists profiled the chemical makeup of at least two different brands of each.
First, pure oil samples were tested to determine how well the spectroscopy method, called Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FT-IR), could differentiate between each one. Then they mixed various amounts of each cooking oil with one of the dietary oils and tested to determine if FT-IR could identify the amounts of individual oils in the compounds.
FT-IR uses wavelengths of light to identify types of chemical bonds. Each type of molecule absorbs light differently, producing a spectrum. Scientists use this spectral information to identify the compound, much the way a fingerprint can identify a person.
"We wanted to see how good FT-IR and common chemical measurement analyses are at differentiating real-world whole samples instead of just one component," Mauer said. "This is the first time this method has been used to differentiate a whole spectrum of food samples, such as the 19 oils used in the study, instead of only comparing two sample types."
Conventional methods for ensuring the makeup of dietary and special use oils are time-consuming, she said. They involve multiple preparation steps and analysis, which take as much as several hours, after the sample preparation and initial analysis are complete. This painstaking process makes traditional purity tests expensive. The FT-IR method took only five minutes once the analytical procedure had been developed.
Many food and pharmaceutical companies already own FT-IR equipment, so there would be no additional cost of using the new purity testing.
In their research, the Purdue scientists tested oil mixtures that had 2 percent to 20 percent by volume of common food oils.
The researchers found that the FT-IR method could identify the adulteration down to 2 percent. They picked this range because food manufacturers have said those are the levels they need to know for quality control of oil mixtures, Mauer said.
The dietary supplement oils tested were almond, apricot kernel, black currant, borage, cod liver, evening primrose, flax seed, grape seed, hazelnut, hemp seed, macadamia nut, olive, pumpkin seed and wheat germ oils. The common food oils were canola, corn, peanut, soybean and sunflower.
Though they didn't test for adulteration levels of oils that would cause allergic reactions in people, such as those allergic to peanut products, Mauer said the study indicated that the method likely could detect lower levels of various oils. Other studies have shown that FT-IR can be used to identify the region where the oil-producing plant was grown and the variety of plant from which it came.
"It's interesting to see that some of the oils, such as canola oil and pumpkin seed oil or hazelnut oil and olive oil, are structurally so similar," Mauer said. "It's based on the fatty acid composition. But while you see dietary claims related to pumpkin seed oil, I don't know of any canola oil being sold in capsules for health purposes."
The other researchers involved with this study were Banu Ozen, postdoctoral fellow, and Ilan Weiss, graduate research assistant, both of the Department of Food Science.
The Purdue University Agricultural Research Programs provided funding for this research.
Writer: Susan A. Steeves, (765) 496-7481, email@example.com
Source: Lisa Mauer, (765) 494-9111, firstname.lastname@example.org
Ag Communications: (765) 494-2722; Beth Forbes, email@example.com; https://www.agriculture.purdue.edu/AgComm/public/agnews/
Related Web site:
A publication-quality photograph is available at https://ftp.purdue.edu/pub/uns/mauer.oil.jpeg.
Dietary Supplement Oil Classification and Detection of Adulteration Using Fourier-Transform Infrared Spectroscopy
Purdue University, Food Science Dept.,
745 Agriculture Mall Drive, West Lafayette, IN 47907
Tel: 765-494-9111, Fax: 765-494-7953
(* To whom correspondence should be addressed)
Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FT-IR) methods and common chemometric techniques (including discriminant analysis (DA), Mahalanobis distances, and Cooman plots were used to classify various types of dietary supplement oils (DSO) and less expensive, common food oils. Rapid FT-IR methods were then developed to detect adulteration of DSO with select common food oils. Spectra of 14 types of DSO and 5 types of common food oils were collected with a FT-IR equipped with a ZnSe-ATR cell and a MCTA detector. Classification of DSO and some common food oils was achieved successfully using FT-IR and chemometrics. Select DSO were adulterated (2 20% vol/vol) with the common food oils that had the closest Mahalanobis distance to them in a Cooman plot based on the DA analysis, and data were also analyzed using a partial least square (PLS) method. The detection limit for the adulteration of DSO was 2% vol/vol. Standard curves to determine the adulterant concentration in DSO were also obtained using PLS with correlation coefficients of >0.9. The approach of using FT-IR in combination with chemometric analyses was successful at classifying oils and detecting adulteration of DSO. (Key words: dietary supplement oils, Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy, FT-IR, adulteration)